Jump to content


Monthly Contributor
  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by bentraje

  1. In R20+, if you go to the sculpt layout, there is a "Volume Mesh" command. 
    This creates a new geometry from the existing object but redistributes the polygons equally. Well, at least more or less. It's not on quads though, but should be good enough for prototyping. 

  2. RE:  if it is possible to anchor/tether the last joint of the tentacle so I can move the first one around freely, 

    I can't check the video. But based on the description above, yes you can. You just need to have an IK without the dynamics. 

    If you wish to have both (with and without dynamics), you'll need to have three joint chain. One is the base. Two is with dynamics. Three is without. Then have the One parent constrained with the two and three. 

    If you haven't done  a set-up like that, try searching for IK and Switch. 

  3. @Jops

    RE: but I don't find it smart, to charge the institutions, that teach your software
    I agree. But it seems like MAXON still got a clout in the DCC market. So, I guess they have their focus elsewhere. 

    RE: And one of it's main purposes is to exchange opinions.
    Indeed, I am exchanging my opinion, and it was firm: Sure, you can request MAXON to lower the price but please understand their decision if they don't (due to their business model) . 
    The OP made his statement. I am made mine. 

    RE: I don't think that phrases like "If push comes to shove, you can always go ahead and use Autodesk or Blender " are very helpful
    To some degree, it doesn't. But its probably the most truthful.
    That's the same argument I made for users that complain the Cinema4D doesn't have much FX tool, use Houdini. 
    or Cinema4D doesn't have proper UV tools, use Blender or RizomUV. 

    Before I mislead you, those complaints have weight, and also my complaints. I am all for creating Cinema4D a one-stop solution and I have submitted several suggestions. But the current state of the matter, Cinema4D cannot be because Cinema4D has a different focus (i..e Mograph, for instance). 

    So that's why if other tools can fit your need, then use it. 

    I am all for criticism for the better but berating is totally unnecessary. @RBarrett has already made his statement and the immediate reply whines "Guys, you should read the post before answering."? That's a bit disrespectful.

  4. @hikarubr

    RE: you totally ignored the context of my post
    I made the post in the context that either the student, teacher or university (all non-profit) buys the license. Either case, I'd still consider it reasonable in this case. 
    Again comparing with the Autodesk and Blender, they have a different business model. 

    If push comes to shove, you can always go ahead and use Autodesk or Blender. Again, respect MAXON's business model. 

    P.S. I meant no offense but try to avoid the whining tone. It doesn't make the case any stronger that what it is. 

  5. How many months is the $75? If its 1 year or even 6 months. That's pretty reasonable to me. 


    While Autodesk is free (and I myself have used a free student version), they have different business model. 
    The entry Maya of free but later on recoups it with high subscription price. And since you already know the software, you might as well pay the subscription to save you some time. 

    I forgot the proper name here's an old explanation from joelonsoftware.com:


    Even better than lock-in is the sneaky version I call stealth lock-in: services which lock you in without your even realizing it. For example, all those new services like PayMyBills.com which receive your bills for you, scan them in, and show them to you on the Internet. They usually come with three months free service. But when the three months are up, if you don’t want to continue with the service, you have no choice but to contact every single bill provider and ask them to change the billing address back to your house. The sheer chore of doing this is likely to prevent you from switching away from PayMyBills.com — better just to let them keep sucking $8.95 out of your bank account every month. Gotcha!

    For the Blender, it would be to get many users as possible. Then recoup the cost from the ecosystem of tutorials/plugins. For instance, BlenderMarket gives a percentage to the BlenderFoundation whenever it makes a purchase. Same business model goes to Wordpress, sort of.  I don't discount the good intention of the Blender to provide a free software, but somebody has to pay the bills. 


    I agree to the argument "Do this feature because Software X is doing this" mostly because it makes the software better but there are some boundaries you have to respect and this includes the business model. 

    Sure, you can request MAXON to lower the price but please understand their decision if they don't (due to their business model 
    P.S. I use Cinema4D mostly for personal work, Maya and Blender for mostly outsourced work. Just want to disclaim that I'm not really a total MAXON fanboy and I did find the perpetual to subscription a bit disappointing considering that I bought my personal copy of Cinema4D just recently (i.e. this year R20 version). 


  6. I use a C4D to Maya modelling pipeline when it involves the mograph. There is MASH in Maya, but its still way easier to manipulate within in C4D.
    For instance, creating banisters on a complicated staircase where client is still yet to approve how many banisters fit in the staircase. 

    Apart from that, Maya has at least the same or more modelling features with Cinema4D. 

    In terms of mesh exchanges, between DCC, I haven't encountered major problems, except may be from Blender to DCC where I cant get around its size conversion. 

  7. Wouldn't it be nice if the Support and MyMaxon site are integrated?
    Currently, I have to type my details (like the 11 C4D digit, ugh) every time I file a bug or request for a support.

    P.S. I sent them a suggestion on this one but just wondering if other uses have the same sentiment and would, uhm, flood them with this suggestion. *wink *wink

  • Create New...